The Infallibility of the Church
Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God; for many false prophets have gone out into the world. By this, you know the Spirit of God: every spirit that confesses that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is from God, and every spirit that does not confess Jesus is not from God. And this is the spirit of the antichrist, of which you have heard that it is coming; and now it is already in the world. Little children, you are from God and have conquered them; for the one who is in you is greater than the one who is in the world. They are from the world; therefore, what they say is from the world, and the world listens to them. We are from God. Whoever knows God listens to us, and whoever is not from God does not listen to us. From this, we know the spirit of truth and the spirit of error.
1 John 4:1-6
The First Epistle of John is traditionally attributed to John the Apostle. Written towards the end of the first century, this letter addresses a community of believers who were likely experiencing internal strife due to false teachings—often associated with early Gnostic movements that denied the true humanity of Christ. The early Christian community faced various heresies, particularly Gnosticism, which posited dualistic views of the world and often denied the Incarnation of Jesus. The phrase “spirit of the antichrist” indicates that there were those who opposed the fundamental tenets of Christianity, leading believers astray from the truth about Christ’s nature. The exhortation to “test the spirits” reflects the community’s need for discernment in a world where many voices were competing for attention. This testing was crucial for maintaining orthodox belief regarding the Incarnation—that Jesus Christ is fully God and fully human.
In Catholic doctrine, the belief in the Incarnation is central. The affirmation that “every spirit that confesses that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is from God” underscores the importance of recognizing Jesus’ true nature. This belief is foundational in the Nicene Creed and central to the Catholic understanding of salvation. The passage emphasizes the authority of the Church and its teachings. The distinction made between those who listen to the apostles (and thus to the Church) and those who do not reflects Catholic belief in the necessity of the Church as the guardian of truth. The Church is seen as guided by the Holy Spirit to discern true doctrine from falsehood (cf. Jn 16:12-13; 14:16; 1 Tim 3:15, etc.).
In discussing the Holy Spirit, the Catholic Church emphasizes this Spirit as the “Spirit of Truth,” actively working within the hearts of believers to provide guidance, inspiration, and assurance. This contrasts sharply with the acknowledgment of a “spirit of error” in the passage, which represents misleading and false teachings that can lead believers astray. The ongoing relevance of this dichotomy resonates in modern discussions about the fidelity of doctrine and the impact of contemporary interpretations of faith.
The comforting assertion, “for the one who is in you is greater than the one who is in the world,” affirms the abiding presence of God within believers. This phrase reassures the faithful that despite the omnipresence of falsehood and deception, the grace and strength provided by God empower them to overcome these challenges. It encapsulates a fundamental aspect of Catholic teaching about God’s protective and transformative power in the life of every believer.
Hence, the Church’s infallibility, particularly in matters of doctrine and faith, is rooted in the belief that Christ established the Church and endowed it with the Holy Spirit to guide it into all truth. The Apostolic teaching authority is a safeguard against the misinformation and heretical ideas that could lead believers astray. In an era where many voices contend for attention, the assurance that the Church, through its magisterial authority, adheres to the same apostolic teachings provides a bulwark against falsehoods.
The text from 1 John not only encourages individuals to be vigilant but also affirms the necessity of the Church in discerning truth from error. By adhering to the traditional teachings passed down through the apostles, believers can remain grounded in the faith that has stood the test of time, contrasting sharply with the shifting ideologies or theologies of groups like the Gnostics. This illuminates the essential role of the Church in maintaining doctrinal purity and guiding its members toward an authentic understanding of faith rooted in Christ’s revelation.
“But [it has, on the other hand, been shown], that the preaching of the Church is everywhere consistent, and continues in an even course, and receives testimony from the prophets, the apostles, and all the disciples…For in the Church,” it is said, “God hath set apostles, prophets, teachers,’ and all the other means through which the Spirit works; of which all those are not partakers who do not join themselves to the Church, but defraud themselves of life through their perverse opinions and infamous behavior. For where the Church is, there is the Spirit of God; and where the Spirit of God is, there is the Church, and every kind of grace; but the Spirit is truth.”
St. Irenaeus, Against Heresies, 3:24 (inter A.D. 180-190)
“For the rock is inaccessible to the serpent, and it is stronger than the gates of Hades which are opposing it, so that because of its strength the gates of Hades do not prevail against it; but the church, as a building of Christ who built His own house wisely upon the rock, is incapable of admitting the gates of Hades which prevail against every man who is outside the rock and the church, but have no power against it.”
Origen, On Matthew, 12:11 (A.D. 244)
“And besides, also, one only Catholic and Apostolic Church, which can never be destroyed, though all the world should seek to make war with it; but it is victorious over every most impious revolt of the heretics who rise up against it. For her Goodman hath confirmed our minds by saying, ‘Be of good cheer, I have overcome the world.’ ”
St. Alexander of Alexandria, Epistle on the Arian Heresy, 12 (A.D. 321)
Catholic Scripture 
Leave a comment